Rare opportunity to own a beautifully rebuilt and turnkey furnished second-tier Payette Lake cottage. This charming 4-bedroom, 3-bath home pairs classic McCall character with an extensive 2024 renovation, including new plumbing, electrical, insulation, roof and siding. Includes 1/5 ownership in a private Payette Lake access parcel and 1/4 ownership in a shared private dock—perfect for boating, swimming and summer days on the lake. A private guest studio above the garage features peek-a-boo lake views, separate entrance, full kitchen, bath and laundry. The oversized ~725 sq. ft. heated garage offers abundant storage, utility sink and kid/dog wash. Additional features include a heated driveway, WiFi-controlled heating and cooling, electric blinds and custom storage. Ideally situated on a quiet dead-end street with no HOA, within walking distance of downtown McCall, Ponderosa State Park and McCall Golf Club. Enjoy the Payette Lake lifestyle without taking on a major renovation—ready to enjoy in every season.
- Heating:
- Electric, Radiant, Ductless/mini Split
- Cooling:
- Ductless/mini Split
- Fireplace:
- One, Insert
- Garage Capacity:
- 2
- Country:
- US
- State:
- ID
- City:
- McCall
- Zipcode:
- 83638
- Street:
- 1619 E Lake St
- Longitude:
- W117° 54' 22''
- Latitude:
- N44° 55' 9.2''
- Master Bedroom Level:
- Main
- Master Bedroom Size:
- 9x11
- Bedroom 2 Level:
- Upper
- Bedroom2 Size:
- 9x12
- Bedroom 3 Level:
- Upper
- Bedroom3 Size:
- 12x11
- Bedroom 4 Level:
- Upper
- Bedroom4 Size:
- 30x15
- Kitchen Level:
- Main
- Kitchen Size:
- 10x12
- Living Room Level:
- Main
- Living Room Size:
- 12x19
- School District:
- McCall-Donnelly Joint District #
- Elementary School:
- McCall
- Middle School:
- Payette Lakes
- High School:
- McCall Donnelly
- Status:
- Active
- Type:
- Single Family
- Level:
- Two Story
- Tax Year:
- 2025
- Taxes:
- $6,859
- Potential Short Sale:
- No
- Age:
- 31 - 50 Years
- Auction:
- No
- Flood Ins Required:
- No
- HUD Owned:
- No
- In Foreclosure:
- No
- Land Size:
- Standard Lot 6000-9999 SF
- Land Lease:
- No
- Home Owner Exempt:
- No
- HOA Frequency:
- Not Applicable
- Virtual Tour:
- https://mountainside-real-estate-photography.aryeo.com/sites/1619-e-lake-st-mccall-id-83638-27253331
- Inc Kitchen Features:
- Breakfast bar, Dishwasher, Disposal, Microwave, Oven/range freestanding, Pantry, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer, Island, Double oven, Other, Countertop-quartz
- Lot Features:
- Public road, Dog run, View, Finished Driveway, Dock, Community
- Water:
- City service
- Land Use:
- Single
- Sprinkler System:
- Auto,Drip,Full
Residential For Sale
1619 E Lake St, McCall, Idaho 83638
- Property Type :
- Residential
- Listing Type :
- For Sale
- Listing ID :
- 98996538
- Price :
- $2,655,000
- Bedrooms :
- 4
- Bathrooms :
- 3
- Apx SqFt :
- 2,160 SqFt
- Year Built :
- 1982
- Lot Area :
- 0.15 SqFt
- Days on Market :
- 33
- Subdivision :
- 0 Not Applicable
- Update Date :
- 09/08/2026 06:10:43
- Status :
- Active
- JoeAnne Santy-Greene
- (208) 947-4609
- (208) 283-6313
- (208) 287-8500
-
